diff --git a/src/THcHelicityScaler.h b/src/THcHelicityScaler.h
index 687825a345f473cd8817ee5f503c85a8241aceff..42cb3c110522a6845e37c4be6ef01cd7651c8940 100644
--- a/src/THcHelicityScaler.h
+++ b/src/THcHelicityScaler.h
@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ public:
   virtual Bool_t IsSeedGood() {return fNBits>=30;}
 
   const std::vector<Double_t> &GetPlusScalers() const { return fHScalers[0]; }
-  const std::vector<Double_t> &GetMinusScalers() const { return fHScalers[0]; }
+  const std::vector<Double_t> &GetMinusScalers() const { return fHScalers[1]; }
   const std::vector<Double_t> &GetScalerSums() const { return fScalerSums; }
   const std::vector<Double_t> &GetAsymmetry() const { return fAsymmetry; }
   const std::vector<Double_t> &GetAsymmetryError() const { return fAsymmetryError; }